| Envelope Component Approach
|
| Complexity |
Simplest |
| Flexibility |
Least flexible |
| Tradeoffs |
Does not allow tradeoffs - each building component must meet or exceed the requirement for that climate zone |
| Calculations |
Fewest calculations |
| Cool roof requirement |
Cool roof is required for low-sloped buildings |
| Overall Envelope Approach |
| Complexity |
More complex |
| Flexibility |
Somewhat flexible |
| Tradeoffs |
Allows tradeoffs - if one building component does not meet the requirement but another exceeds it, it may offset the component that does not meet the requirement |
| Calculations |
Requires more calculations |
| Cool roof requirement |
Cool roof is not necessarily required |
| Whole Building Performance Approach
|
| Complexity |
Most complex |
| Flexibility |
Most flexible |
| Tradeoffs |
Allows tradeoffs - if one building component does not meet the requirement but another exceeds it, it may offset the component that does not meet the requirement |
| Calculations |
Requires computer simulations |
| Cool roof requirement |
Cool roof is not necessarily required |